Best CRM for Nonprofits
Donor Management Systems Head-to-Head
Quick Summary
Nonprofits require specialized CRM capabilities beyond traditional sales CRMs. The best nonprofit CRMs combine donor management, fundraising campaign tracking, volunteer coordination, grant management, and event planning. This comparison analyzes the top 5 donor management systems purpose-built for nonprofits in 2025.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Bloomerang | Virtuous CRM | Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud | Kindful (by Bloomerang) | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $125/mo | $199/mo | 10 free users | Free | Free* |
| Free Version | |||||
| Donor Management | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good | Good | Good |
| Fundraising Tools | Very Good | Excellent | Good | Good | Excellent |
| Email Marketing | Very Good | Excellent | Add-on | Good | Good |
| Volunteer Management | Basic | Good | Excellent | None | Basic |
| Grant Tracking | None | Good | Excellent | None | None |
| Ease of Use | Excellent | Very Good | Fair | Excellent | Excellent |
| Reporting | Very Good | Excellent | Excellent | Basic | Basic |
Detailed Analysis
Bloomerang
Strengths
- Built specifically for nonprofits
- Excellent donor retention tools and analytics
- Intuitive, easy-to-use interface
- Strong email marketing capabilities
- Automatic tax receipting
- Great training resources and support
- Online donation forms included
Weaknesses
- Higher price point than some alternatives
- Limited customization options
- Volunteer management features are basic
- No grant management module
Virtuous CRM
Strengths
- Modern, responsive fundraising approach
- AI-powered donor insights and recommendations
- Excellent automation capabilities
- Strong integration ecosystem
- Beautiful, modern interface
- Marketing automation included
- Comprehensive analytics and reporting
Weaknesses
- Premium pricing
- Can be complex for very small organizations
- Requires time investment to master advanced features
- Annual contract required
Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud
Strengths
- 10 free licenses through Power of Us program
- Enterprise-grade features and scalability
- Extensive customization options
- Massive integration ecosystem
- Strong grant management
- Volunteer engagement tools (Volunteers for Salesforce)
- Program management capabilities
Weaknesses
- Steep learning curve
- Implementation can be expensive
- Requires dedicated administrator
- Can be overwhelming for small organizations
- Support can be inconsistent
Kindful (by Bloomerang)
Strengths
- Free plan available
- User-friendly interface
- Online donation forms
- Email marketing included
- Automatic tax receipts
- Good mobile apps
- Integrates with many fundraising tools
Weaknesses
- Limited features on free plan
- Basic reporting capabilities
- No volunteer management
- Lacks advanced automation
- Being merged into Bloomerang platform
Givebutter
Strengths
- Completely free CRM
- Modern, beautiful interface
- Online fundraising tools included
- Peer-to-peer fundraising
- Event ticketing and management
- Text-to-donate
- Very easy to use
Weaknesses
- Platform fee on donations (1.75% + payment processing)
- Newer platform with fewer proven track record
- Basic CRM features compared to dedicated systems
- Limited advanced reporting
- No grant management
Final Verdict
Virtuous CRM leads the pack for nonprofits embracing modern, responsive fundraising strategies. Its AI-powered insights, automation capabilities, and comprehensive donor engagement tools justify the premium price for growth-focused organizations. However, Bloomerang remains the gold standard for organizations prioritizing donor retention with its intuitive interface and excellent support. For budget-conscious small nonprofits, Givebutter offers surprising functionality at no cost (beyond payment processing fees). Large enterprises should consider Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud for maximum customization and scalability.
- Small nonprofit (<$500k budget): Givebutter (free) or Kindful - Low/no cost with essential features
- Mid-size nonprofit ($500k-$5M): Bloomerang - Best balance of features, ease of use, and support
- Growth-focused nonprofit: Virtuous - Advanced automation and responsive fundraising tools
- Large nonprofit (>$5M budget): Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud - Enterprise capabilities and customization
- Grant-dependent organization: Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud - Best grant management capabilities
- Volunteer-heavy organization: Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud with Volunteers for Salesforce
At a Glance
Key Decision Factors
- Donor management and engagement tracking
- Fundraising and campaign management
- Grant tracking and reporting
- Volunteer management
- Affordability for nonprofit budgets
- Ease of use for non-technical staff
Related Comparisons
Explore More CRM Resources
Continue exploring to make the best CRM decision
Ready to Make Your Decision?
Explore detailed reviews or find more industry-specific comparisons.